Quoting Han from 20:51, 28th Jul 2005
Someone (apologies, I forget who...) suggested that Dumbledore might have a horcrux somewhere....
....so we're assuming DD has killed someone?
interesting...
Quoting novium from 06:59, 29th Jul 2005
what you are all forgetting is if you do a horcrux thingy, you turn evil.Quoting Han from 20:51, 28th Jul 2005
Someone (apologies, I forget who...) suggested that Dumbledore might have a horcrux somewhere....
....so we're assuming DD has killed someone?
interesting...
[hr]
I have no witty signature.
Quoting Han from 23:46, 30th Jul 2005
Not necessarily - as far as I understand it, it takes an act of evil - killing someone, to create a horcrux. Thus the likelihood is that you are evil if you create a horcrux. BUT I also think it would only *make* you evil if you did it multiple times and fractured your soul too much.
If that makes any sense...Quoting novium from 06:59, 29th Jul 2005
what you are all forgetting is if you do a horcrux thingy, you turn evil.Quoting Han from 20:51, 28th Jul 2005
Someone (apologies, I forget who...) suggested that Dumbledore might have a horcrux somewhere....
....so we're assuming DD has killed someone?
interesting...
[hr]
I have no witty signature.
Quoting Rennie from 19:39, 31st Jul 2005
Isn't this a kids book? Or have I missed the point.
Quoting ninman from 11:56, 28th Jul 2005
I know what one of the horcruxes is, and I'm just curious to know if anyone else has figured it out. I'll give you a clue, it's something that is in Dumbledore's office.
Quoting Maggie from 17:18, 31st Jul 2005Quoting ninman from 11:56, 28th Jul 2005
I know what one of the horcruxes is, and I'm just curious to know if anyone else has figured it out. I'll give you a clue, it's something that is in Dumbledore's office.
Well, aren't you going to tell us what it is??? Dumbledore said he was pretty certain that Gryffindor's sword wasn't one of them (I think he said it "remains safe").
Return to The Sinner's Main Board
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 23 guests