by The_Farwall on Sun May 04, 2003 10:17 am
There's not much to say as to why, except that Philophobia is better. It's an album's worth of 13 consistantly good songs. The lyrics are at their most graphic (one of Arab Strap's characteristic great points, the first line of the Album is "It was the biggest cock you've ever seen. But you've no idea where that cock has been"), the songs are varied but all pretty damn good.
I've always thought the songs on elephant shoe are a bit too lowkey and samey, a bit dull. And The Red Thread suffers from the same problem to a lesser extent.
Plus, ever since Philophobia Aiden Moffat seems to have gotten a lot less angry which means the songs/lyrics have lost a lot of the bite that Philophobia and The Weekend Never Starts... have.
To be honest though, I'd recommend you go for Mad For Sadness for that era of Arab Strap. It's a live album consisting pretty much entirely of Philophobia material, and has some amazing versions.
EDIT: Haven't heard the new one yet so can't say.
[hr][s]"A bell is a cup... Until it is struck"
- wire[/s]
[s]Hanging on in quiet desperation is the English way.[/s]