by BenEsq on Wed May 21, 2008 2:40 pm
Unfortunately, owing to Clement and other former Rectors' performances at other - and I do stress other - institutions there have been numerous attempts to unseat the Rector from chair - particularly both here and at Aberdeen. I'm not casting any judgement on Sir Clement, I thought he brought a lot to the role, but the moves to unseat Rector from Chair do stem from his time. Indeed, historically there have been moves to unseat Scottish Rectors from chair going back some 50 years - ranging from government to individual Court members attempts. I should also add that there are currently significant components on all Scottish Courts with Rectors that don't like a student elected or in Edinburgh's case student/staff elected chairing Court. It comes down frequently to disagreements over what constitutes good governance (many governors would prefer a business model) and interpretation of statute: one of the main issues being the division of roles between University chairmans and the Rector. Statute reads that the Rector 'presides' over Court Meetings, which although this blatantly means chair - there are those that disagree.
With references to the handbook, stipulations such as Rectors must attend a majority of Court meetings per year are basic safeguards for the position. Surely it bodes well for the position of Rector and student representation, if candidates that get in for the running understand that it is a serious role with time commitments to which they must be able to adhere. To get the University to accept and support other roles of the Rector bolsters the position.
I'm happy to say that this has been resolved at St Andrews (for the present) though things haven't boded so well in Aberdeen.
I realise and know that every Rector is different, with their own specialities and skills and profiles that they can lend to the student body, but they must be able to chair the Court competently or the main point of their position, which I argue is to safeguard student interests and representation, is lost.
[hr]
Lions and tigers and bears...Oh my!
Lions and tigers and bears...Oh my!