by Matthew on Thu Jun 05, 2003 11:50 am
[s]Unregisted User diana wrote on 00:15, 5th Jun 2003:
looking for information on St.Andrews' medical program.
I will write an article about the St Andrews medical programme for the Sinners' Guide. I don't know that much about the GKT medical degree specifically, so I can't really compare them that well, but the main differences between St Andrews and elsewhere generally that I can think of off the top of my head are:
[l]
[li] Completely separate clinical and pre-clinical programme at St Andrews, with virtually no patient contact whatsoever in the first 3 years.
[li] It takes 6 years to do the full medical degree at St Andrews as oppose to 5 years elsewhere.
[li] There is a full anatomy course with dissection, whereas I believe some other courses have gone over to computer reconstructions and less emphasis on anatomy.
[li] Small class - only about 120 students in each year, which is smaller than most other medical schools.
[li] A lecture-based course with very little in the way of Problem Based Learning (PBL) during the pre-clinical years.
[li] Subject-based rather than systems-based organisation of teaching.
[/l]
I enjoy the course, but it depends what you're into. If you're main interest is in clinical medicine, then other places are possibly better for this, whereas if you also have an interest in learning about the scientific and biological background to what you learn, then maybe St Andrews offers this.
The course is generally well-regarded. Some people say much of what you learn has little relevance to your future clinical career, which is possibly true. In terms of future jobs, your final MBChB actually comes from Manchester rather than St Andrews, and the Manchester MBChB is thought of as being a good qualification.
Also, take into account the surroundings of the whole university. Although differences in the course are important, also think whether you would prefer to be in a small, historic, quiet, Scottish seaside town, or in the middle of a busy, bustling noisy capital....
Also, along with extensive reorganisation in the Medical School over the last year, with the reintroduction of the Faculty of Medicine and a number of senior staff changes, there is going to be an extensive revision of the curriculum in the next few years, so much of what I've said may change....