Home

TheSinner.net

Another weekend, another IV, another St Andrews victory...

Your opportunity to discuss goings on in the Debating Society, recent debates or any issues you believe are important. Questions or queries can be addressed to the moderator at debates@st-andrews.ac.uk.

Another weekend, another IV, another St Andrews victory...

Postby John Stewart on Sun Mar 13, 2005 12:12 am

Results form the aberdeen IV:

In the final:

PROPOSITION:

1P - Composite (Kat Robson & Keith Newman)
2P - Glasgow (Niall Rowantree & Andrew Forsyth)

OPPOSITION:

1O - St Andrews A (Jason Vit & John Stewart)
2O - St Andrews B (Doug Cochrane & Connie Grieve)

Winners - St Andrews A (John & Jason)

Congrats to Doug and Connie on a well deserved IV final debut, and a bloody good performance in the final to boot!
John Stewart
 
Posts: 665
Joined: Mon Sep 23, 2002 4:29 pm

Re:

Postby Laura on Sun Mar 13, 2005 1:56 am

Congratulations, guys.
"When I came back to Dublin, I was courtmartialled in my absence and sentenced to death in my absence, so I said they could shoot me in my absence."
Laura
 
Posts: 741
Joined: Sun Oct 19, 2003 3:15 pm

THE TAB

Postby John Stewart on Sun Mar 13, 2005 12:46 pm

Here are the results for the competition as a whole:

TEAM TAB

1. St Andrews A (Stewart & Vit), (3,3,2,3), 11 (640)
2. Composite 1 (Newman & Robson), (3,2,3,3), 11 (637)
3. Glasgow (Rowantree & Forsyth),(2,3,1,2), 8 (621)
4. St Andrews B (Cochrane & Grieve), (2,2,2,1), 7 (595)
5. Composite 2 (MacDonald & Hamilton), (3,1,3,0), 7 (589)
6. St Andrews E (Lolachi & Whitbread), (0,2,2,3), 7 (554)
7. Composite 3 (Dawson & Chalmers), (1,3,0,2), 6 (627)
8. Dundee (Harrison & Reid), (3,0,1,2), 6 (584)
9. St Andrews C (McGreevy & Jennings), (2,0,3,1), 6 (570)
10. Newcastle (Mace & Donnelly), (0,3,0,3), 6 (558)
11. GUU B (Maloney & Armstrong), (1,2,2,0), 5 (547)
12. St Andrews F (Blair & Rhodes), (2,1,1,1), 5 (528)
13= GUU A (Anderson & Hardman), (1,0,3,0), 4 (531)
13= Composite 4 (Bruno & Shirres), (1,1,0,2), 4 (531)
15. St Andrews D (Rollings & Harman), (0,1,0,1), 2 (506)
16. St Andrews G (Winston & Majedavia), (0,0,1,0), 1 (495)


SPEAKER TAB

1. Keith Newman (Composite 1), (77,78,83,84), 322
2= John Stewart (St Andrews A), (82,80,80,78), 320
2= Jason Vit (St Andrews A), (80,78,81,81), 320

4. Mark Dawson (Composite 3), (77,82,75,82), 316
5. Kat Robson (Composite 1), (77,77,79,82), 315
6. Andrew Forsyth (Glasgow), (81,75,79,77), 312
7. James Chalmers (Composite 3), (75,83,78,75), 311
8. Niall Rowentree (Glasgow), (74,77,79,79), 309
9. Doug Cochrane (St Andrews B), (71,75,76,78), 300
10. Jenni Harrison (Dundee), (78,75,73,72), 298
11= Connie Grieve (St Andrews B), (70,73,76,76), 295
11= Ewan MacDonald (Composite 2), (71,76,78,70), 295
13. Colin Hamilton (Composite 2), (72,73,75,74), 294
14. Ben McGreevy (St Andrews C), (77,67,73,70), 287
15. Ciara Reid (Dundee), (75,71,72,68), 286
16. Alex Jennings (St Andrews C), (75,66,70,72), 283
17. Clifford Mace (Newcastle), (67,70,70,73), 280
18. Rachel Whitbread (St Andrews E), (76,63,70,70), 279
19. Chris Donnelly (Newcastle), (64,72,71,71), 278
20= Ramin Locachi (St Andrews E), (71,65,67,72), 275
20= Neil Armstrong (GUU B), (69,69,67,70), 275
22. Richard Anderson (GUU A), (72,66,72,63), 273
23. James Maloney (GUU B), (68,68,66,70), 272
24= Peter Blair (St Andrews F), (68,67,66,65), 266
24= Graham Bruno (Composite 4), (66,66,64,70), 266
26. Stephen Shirres (Composite 4), (66,66,62,71), 265
27. Elizabeth Rhodes (St Andrews F), (67,67,64,64), 262
28. Jonny Hardman (GUU A), (65,64,69,60), 258
29. Rob Rollings (St Andrews D), (68,60,58,69), 255
30= Alison Winston (St Andrews G), (64,58,65,64), 251
30= Luke Harman (St Andrews D), (66,60,57,68), 251
32. Jassel Majevadia (St Andrews G), (61,58,62,63), 244


Congratualtions to all, particularly to all those for whom this was their first IV. A good all round performance.
John Stewart
 
Posts: 665
Joined: Mon Sep 23, 2002 4:29 pm

Re:

Postby Ewan MacDonald on Mon Mar 14, 2005 1:06 pm

It's amazing, you speak with a Dundonian and they won't even italicise your name anymore :P
Seriously very well done to John and Jason for winning (again). It seems to have become a habit.
I would also personally like to congratulate Doug and Connie on breaking to their first final. I was (un)lucky enough to be opposite them in three rounds and they spoke very very well. It is fabulous to see St Andrews being able to produce not just one, but two very good teams, and is a tremendous example of the effectiveness of John's training programme.


[hr]

Nulla fere causa est, in qua non femina litem moverit
Juvenal 242
When bad men combine, the good must associate; else they will fall, one by one, an unpitied sacrifice in a contemptible struggle.
Edmund Burke
Ewan MacDonald
 
Posts: 285
Joined: Thu Oct 23, 2003 3:32 pm


Return to Union Debating Society

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest

cron